Search Site
Menu
The Fifth Amendment in the Information Age

When we go on line, most of us are unaware of just how visible we are and how easy it is for con artists and fraudsters to use information we provide to relieve us of our possessions or exploit our social connections. While nefarious hackers “phish” for information on the Web, numerous legitimate organizations, such as Skype or the Maryland Health Connection, collect profile information for social or business purposes, but afford only limited privacy rights.  

Fifth Amendment protection online

You may wonder if the Fifth Amendment protect statements made on sites like Facebook. It does protect against compelled self-incrimination. A statement taken in violation of this amendment cannot be used as evidence against the maker of the statement. However, statements made on a social networking site are not protected by the Fifth Amendment. If incriminating statements are protected by a password, and a suspect is asked to provide it by a government agent, the suspect may have a Fifth Amendment right to refuse. Thus, one court held that requiring a suspect to provide a password to a laptop would force her to admit ownership of the laptop and would violate the Fifth Amendment.  

You had the right to remain silent

In Salinas v. Texas, a case involving a double shooting, the police recovered shotgun shells and spoke with a suspect who agreed to go to the police station. He wasn’t in custody and wasn’t given Miranda warnings. He answered questions, but when asked whether he expected that the bullets found on the scene would match his gun, he became silent, looked down at the ground and shuffled his feet. The prosecutor argued that an innocent person would not have been silent, and the jury convicted the defendant. The Supreme Court held that a witness under questioning must “take the Fifth” and expressly invoke the Fifth Amendment to enjoy its protections.

The lessons here are obvious. The target of a criminal investigation should not speak to the investigator without a lawyer present, and what you put out there on the Web may be used against you. The Law Offices of Paul Chatzky is unwavering in its commitment to your defense, working aggressively to ensure that you are appropriately advised and protected.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Paul Chatzky Attorney Photo
Paul Chatzky
Founder

About Born in Havana, Cuba, Paul Chatzky is fluent in Spanish and English, enabling him to effectively represent a wider range of individuals and businesses. He is AV® Preeminent™ Peer Review Rated by Martindale-Hubbell®, and is listed among Illinois Super Lawyers, which is a reflection of his high ethical standards and exceptional legal knowledge. As…

Deborah E. Chatzky Attorney Photo
Deborah E. Chatzky
Paralegal

About Prior to joining the firm as a paralegal, Debbie was employed by major banking institutions as a loan processor and as an executive secretary. Debbie was also employed as an administrative assistant for the Board of Jewish Education. Having majored in Sociology, Debbie graduated from the University of Florida in 1980. Debbie completed her…

Client Reviews
  • lawyers
    5.0/5.0

    Paul Chatzky is well educated, knows in and outs in terms of law, keeps everything under control, responds to emails, returns phone calls almost immediately. Very professional and extremely detail-oriented lawyer. Highly recommended.

    Read more

    Client

  • lawyers
    5.0/5.0

    Mr. Chatzky is very responsive, ethical and effective. I’m extremely happy with the service and I would highly recommend this law office to anyone seeking legal help

    Read more

    Client

  • lawyers
    5.0/5.0

    Mr. Chatzky is truly superb at his job. His knowledge base is profound, and he approached my situation with honesty and integrity. I knew immediately that he had every intention to obtain the best outcome for me and that he had thought of every possi...

    Read more

    Client

  • lawyers
    5.0/5.0

    I highly recommend Paul Chatzky as a high capable and honest attorney who genuinely cares about his clients and is highly committed to supporting their best interests. He lived up to the high expectations that I had and was willing as hard as me to m...

    Read more

    Client

  • lawyers
    5.0/5.0

    Paul Chatzky is always very responsive, professional, and a pleasure to work with.

    Read more

    Client

See all reviews
AWARDS
Contact us

Quick Contact Form